Written by: Opinder Liddar
These days, finding a large, open plot with no design constraints is nearly impossible. Self-builders and their designers now consider sites that are part of, or between, existing structures. These compact spaces can make excellent homes in great locations, if designed smartly. A tight site imposes constraints, but once you find your preferred area, a substantial home may still be possible even on a small plot. This article explores what is required for designs on tight sites and what to consider when evaluating potential plots in desirable locations.
Impact on Neighbouring Amenity:
To be approved by local planning, your proposal must not negatively impact ‘neighbouring amenity’. This means your design:
  • Must not overlook your neighbours’ property or private garden space
  • Should not be imposing (its scale will need to be in line with the buildings on either side)
  • Must make sure there is not going to be any loss of light to the windows of your neighbours’ habitable rooms
Each local authority has a design guide that may set the distances that are permitted from one window to the next. It may also show how to calculate whether your proposal is likely to block out light, so make sure that you and your designer take steps to review such requirements, perhaps even before you commit to the site. Look at the spacing between neighbouring buildings, as your design will probably need to replicate this in the siting of your new home. If the site is on a road where there are mainly detached buildings with decent gaps between the properties, your design will likely be required to maintain this openness between buildings to stop the street from becoming ‘cramped’.

Look at the height of local buildings too. If the plot is narrow, can you accommodate a second floor in the design? We have worked on many tight sites and those where the heights of buildings were restricted to 8.1 metres, which can just about accommodate 3 floors. Where a height of 8.5 metres or more is permitted, 3 floors are certainly possible, and this is certainly a route to explore in your design. The ‘amenity’ of an area is important too. This includes the tranquillity of the area, and the private rear gardens should be spaces for you and your neighbours to enjoy without disturbance. Some local authorities resist ‘backland development’ because this can bring vehicular traffic deeper into a site, and this may mean that neighbours hear the noise of traffic movement in their gardens, which were previously quiet spaces.

Minimum space standards:
 
The government has set out Nationally Described Space Standards, which set out minimum gross internal floor areas and storage requirements as part of the planning requirements for different house types. Using the standards, draw out your room sizes as the design develops; I recommend that you and your designer focus on the needs of the house occupants and include an appropriate number of bedrooms rather than trying to squeeze in additional bedrooms simply because it may increase the value of your home if you were to sell it.
Remember that these minimum standards tend to be dimensions adopted by mass developers’ house sizes rather than the sizes you may be hoping for in your self-build house. I expect that if you are designing your own home, you will want your bedrooms to be far larger than the minimum size and probably hope to accommodate an ensuite bathroom.
Garden space & bin stores:

As well as space standards for rooms, most local authorities have minimum garden sizes for dwellings. Gardens need to be usable amenity spaces and most of it private, so it is unlikely to include all of the front garden where that is exposed to a public street or path; typically, this is at least 50 square metres for up to 2-bedroom houses and 100 square metres for properties of 3 bedrooms or larger. Make sure that your plot is accurately measured out so that even on a sketch scheme, you can design a comfortably sized garden. The minimum garden space area is, in reality, quite small and is likely to be the size of a garden that you typically see on mass-developer sites; this is often why people feel that properties on these types of development look and feel crammed in.

Good house design should be about how internal and external spaces relate and interact with each other. On tight sites, outdoor spaces are important for day-to-day living. Consider using recessed balcony spaces at upper levels to improve your external space. Most planning applications will not be considered until you have shown your provision for recycling, food, and non-recycling bin storage. Ensure your layouts allow for storage in realistic areas, for example, if it can be avoided, you do not want to have these located next to opening windows of habitable rooms.

Parking:

The Highways Department for your area will have standards for the amount of car and bicycle parking that you need for your home. This will depend on where the site is. If the site is within a built-up urban area with good public transport links, you may well find that cycle parking is the only parking needed, as the expectation is that you do not need a car, so space for parking is not required.

If you are in a less urban environment, you can expect that you will need at least 2 car parking spaces on your site. Planning rules may require that cars have sufficient space to be able to turn around on site so that they can exit in a forward gear. This can take up a large area of your tight plot. Even if you drive a small car, you will likely need to accommodate spaces that are 2.5m wide and 5m deep for the scheme to meet the authority’s requirements. We have used this design constraint as a design influence and created upper floors that cantilever or project over the ground floor parking space. This is a very effective means of providing space at upper levels. In some designs, we have moved the living accommodation to the first floor, which then has more available space, a better view of the surrounding area, and can include multi-purpose balconies.

Sustainability & modern methods of construction:

Aim high and focus on excellent fabric and air-tightness in your design. With a tight site, you will find that alternate methods of construction will give you different volumes of internal living space. With a traditional masonry construction, your external walls could be over 400mm thick, and you could be losing almost 3m from the width of your plot to construct the necessary scaffold within your site. Try and negotiate with your neighbours to place the scaffold partly onto their land in order to construct the building in this way.

An ICF wall could be around a similar thickness, but could go up a lot more quickly, which limits the time you need to have the scaffold in place. A timber frame wall could be closer to 300mm thick, and an external scaffold is only needed to apply external finishes, i.e., for a much shorter timeframe.

This means that, depending upon the construction method you choose, you could gain an extra 20 centimetres of space internally on a tight site and, if you can negotiate with your neighbours for limited scaffold timeframes, perhaps gain a further 2 metres of internal space.

Unfortunately, due to the failings of overzealous developers and uncontrolled construction, basement designs are currently on the naughty step for tight sites. Many planning departments and insurers refuse to consider or provide insurance coverage for basement constructions. This is a shame, particularly when land is at such a premium in this country. If done well, basement design and construction can provide a huge increase in the amount of space available for infill and compact sites. When basements were easier to achieve, you could get natural light into these areas fairly easily and/or place plant rooms, gyms, or movie rooms into these zones, releasing the upper floors for habitable space.

On particularly tight sites, decisions about how you use the space available to you are crucial to maximise the design you can achieve. To include a basement in your design, expect that you will
need specialist designers and contractors to carry out this particular type of work, and understand that a basement may be unnecessarily expensive to realise.

In Summary:

A plot, where there is already an existing dwelling, is likely to be considered as an appropriate sustainable location for another dwelling, rather than receiving the resistance that comes from site proposals located in the Greenbelt or open countryside. If you are struggling to find plots in the area where you would like to live, perhaps you could approach an existing building owner to see if an infill plot may suit both of your needs.

This will be beneficial to you as you can create your own home in the area/community of your choosing and provide a financial boost for the current owner, which may mean that they can stay in their home longer. With the knowledge of what to look out for and good design, it is possible to create amazing homes in small plots which have a wealth of space that will suit your needs.

To meet the targets for new housing that this country needs, we need the planning system to enable more of this type of development and relax previous constraints, e.g., matching the height or depth of a new plot design to neighbouring buildings or maintaining wide open spaces in built-up settlement areas. Indeed, with good design and appropriate site inspections, it is possible to create beautiful homes in these types of locations that complement the setting and have a positive impact on the neighbouring area, producing well-built, sustainable self-build homes.

Still have questions?

We offer a free consultation, online or at your property. This is the perfect chance to chat through your ideas and have an architect answer any questions you may have.

To book, use our online booking calendar or get in touch via:

Call 01865 407722

Email: enquiry@lapdarchitects.co.uk

Call us

We’re available to chat about your dream home any time Monday – Friday, 9am-5pm

01865 407722