Building your own forever home is a once-in-a-lifetime experience. This is likely to be one of your life’s biggest emotional and financial investments, and your objective is to create the home you have always wanted.
However, we’ve met too many people who, given the opportunity, would have done things differently and wish they had known what to ask at the outset. From many years of work with clients and with visitors to the ‘Build It Live’ expert sessions, we understand that there are several areas that people want to be aware of and need to be aware of to understand what to expect from their own journey in realising their self-build home.
This article proposes the key questions that you should ask a house designer before you employ them. Hopefully, the answers to these questions will avert disappointment in your project and will help you realise your vision and set realistic expectations for you and your designer from the outset on your journey to build your home.
What house design experience do you have?
Not everyone has the skills to design a home. Creating something that works well for you and looks great to you for many years to come requires experience in residential design. Delivering these two important aspects of design is only two of the critical steps on a journey that is becoming increasingly challenging to navigate, given the amount of regulation that underpins making your ideas into reality.
Your first question is going to be about your designer’s experience in house design and their understanding of residential building regulations. Your designer may have a commercial background. Understanding how residential space and building regulations work is very different from understanding non-residential building construction. We’ve seen an example where someone employed a designer more used to commercial designs that didn’t transfer well to designing a home. Many modern houses are pristine but can feel clinical and lack soul when you live in them; others look like commercial buildings and are therefore unlikely to be supported at the planning stage. Even if such designs are realised, they may not carry value when the time comes to sell the property, due to their unusual commercial design.
You need to ensure that you are going to be getting a home that suits your needs and one that creates the kind of ambience you need to feel relaxed. When you interview your designer, ask them (and their clients) about the homes that they have designed. Whilst the costs of creating your own home are going to be significant, it is the significance of the design that will stay with you every day for the time you remain in your house, and you do not want to live in a building that does not function well as your home.
Why do I need a designer if I have a plan already?
You employ a designer for their expertise, so they will:
-
Use their skills to encourage and to collate your thoughts and ideas.
-
Use their creativity to show you other solutions that will make you think about what you need and want in a new light.
We don’t see much point in appointing a designer who only draws up your own ideas. We would expect your designer to augment your ideas and to offer their genuine opinion on what you have shown them, and to suggest alternate solutions that will develop your design ideas.
Your designer mustn’t completely disregard your input and show you designs that will look great on a designer’s website but have no bearing on what you wanted. Our job is to understand what you want and to offer you a variety of informed choices to develop your initial ideas into something that is an improvement upon where you started. Remember that this is your home; you need to have the final say about what you do or do not like. Do not let anyone else push you into corners that do not respect what you want. When you are interviewing for your designer, ask how they perceive your design journey will go and how options will be put forward for consideration as the design evolves for your home.
How will your designer communicate with you during your journey?
What you have in mind may well be completely different to what your designer is thinking, and unless they spend time getting to know you and understand what your goals are for your new home, the journey is going to be difficult for you both. At lapd architects, we spend a lot of time getting to understand our clients’ objectives, functional requirements and sustainability targets, and we discuss planning strategies with clients before we are appointed.
We put ourselves in our client’s shoes and aim to understand their journey from their point of view rather than assuming they will know how everything will pan out. As designers, we portray your journey in key stages to show you what has to happen at each stage so that we both know, at the outset, what is going to be produced and how and when that will happen.
If you have not built your own home before, how will you know about the key stages and components of your project? What sustainability reviews need to be understood before you submit your design to the planning authority? How long does a planning application take to be determined? Can you start on site immediately after you receive the planning approval? Why would a warranty be required, and is that the same or different to Building Regulations?
We know this, however, we never assume that our clients do and explaining this to them improves the working relationship between client and designer. In so doing, everyone can follow a clear programme of what has to happen and when, and all focus together upon the house becoming a reality. We also highlight the key anxiety points along the journey and explain how we are going to tackle them for our clients so that they worry about the right thing at the right time, rather than worrying about everything all the time.
Good communication with your designer is a two-way street; you will have realistic expectations for the journey and be focused on the right things as the design evolves.
How will you manage costs?
You may have the most wonderful design from your designer, but if you can’t afford to build it, there is no point in spending all that time and cost on the design. Design and costs must go hand in hand for the project to become a reality. We’ve been amazed at just how many times we’ve heard that there has been no cost checking by either the designer or the client during the design stage before any planning application was made. People have been in tears when they tell me that it’s taken a year or more to get to a planning approval, get technical drawings and go out to tender, only to find out that their project is too expensive to build!
You should discuss your construction budget before you appoint your designer. Even if you do not want to declare your budget, your designer should be able to tell you the approximate cost of building a home to suit your brief. This may be a rough figure based on typical construction costs per square metre. Once you reach a stage where you are happy with the design presented to you, a cost analysis is crucial, and ideally, you will be given something more robust than square metre rates. There are a number of relatively inexpensive pricing providers that you can use to do this, even if your designer can’t provide this service. However, it is preferable that your designer does this as they will then understand the whole of the project and be able to interpret a cost plan to make sure everything has an appropriate allowance to it.
When we price projects, we have a clear understanding of where the money is being spent within a project and how costs can be saved for our clients. Usually, making the building slightly smaller is not going to have a significant impact on the overall construction costs, which is why pricing on a £/sqm rate is risky at this early stage. The more significant savings will be made from the level of specification for your finishes, the types of windows, electrical and heating systems, the kind of kitchen(s), bathroom(s) and staircase(s), where the bigger savings can be made. It is useful for clients to see where the money goes in a construction project and where savings or different ways to procure certain items can bring the costs of the project down.
There will be a variety of different solutions to address tensions between the design and the construction costs. Make sure your designer can manage this well for you.
What technical design experience do you have for a project like mine?
A good designer will also understand how the building that they design can be constructed. In reality, you could build anything these days if you had the money for it. So, a great designer needs to know how to create a design that looks great, and that will not cost you the earth to realise it.
Building standards, including thermal performance and airtightness, must be taken into account in the initial design and carried through to the technical design of the building. This technology will contribute to the comfort and running costs of your home for the life of the building. They help to meet your sustainability criteria before you start to add gadgets like solar panels and/or heat pumps.
Your home must also comply with Building Regulations. These regulations fill many lever arch folders, and they are only the minimum standards. Your designer should be able to show that your design can exceed these and explain the benefits of doing so.
lapd Architects will often take on the role of ‘lead consultant’ and will manage many other consultants that you may require for your project. Certainly, a structural engineer will be required for your project, but you could also benefit from having heating and ventilation specialists on board. Your designer needs to be able to tell you which consultants are appropriate for your project.
Each consultant’s fees must be included in the overall project cost, and the implications of the actions that each individual consultant is recommending must be coordinated within the technical package so that the end project seamlessly accommodates all their requirements. For example, how will the ventilation ducts be run through your home by the ventilation engineer so that they do not clash with where the structural engineer has placed steel within the building? Or how will you ensure that the revealed detail of a rendered building suits the timber frame and window? Your designer should be thinking through all of these issues and resolving them with the other consultants or suppliers for your project during the technical design stage, and not when the project is on site.
What is your understanding of modern methods of construction?
The options that are available to you to build your home have grown rapidly over the last decade. No longer are the majority of projects a masonry cavity construction. Timber frames in their various guises of stick, panel or even SIP (structural insulated panel) structures are becoming more mainstream. This form of construction allows us to meet more stringent building regulations for thermal performance and speed of construction. ICF (Insulated Concrete Formwork) is also gaining traction as a form of construction.
Each method has its pros and cons, and your designer needs to be well-versed in a variety of construction methods so that they can determine which will best suit your design and your long-term needs. Many new types of construction may not be covered by your warranty provider or may make obtaining a mortgage harder for you.
Balancing the costs, construction methods and time that a project will take are important considerations in the design of the project; your designer needs to be able to understand this and advise you accordingly.
How will you make my house green?
Whilst many mass housing developers seem to want to avoid sustainable measures in their buildings, most self-builders are looking for the best quality of construction in their homes. The basic principles of ‘maximise insulation’ and ‘get good levels of air-tightness’ are easy to achieve and will not add huge costs to your projects. Your designer should understand these principles and not ignore them, and make up for sustainability by lip-serving measures such as sticking on some solar panels.
Your designer needs to demonstrate to you a holistic understanding of making your home sustainable, both in terms of construction materials and sustainable systems and where best to focus your efforts before applying the gadgets. Passivhaus principles are an excellent standard to adopt without paying for the full formal Passivhaus certification. Having focused on keeping heat in and lowering your heating demand, your designer should be comfortable in discussing appropriate methods to provide heat and hot water with you.
Would a gas boiler and/or heat pumps be appropriate to your design, future goals and current budget? Are you better off investing in triple-glazing compared to rainwater harvesting? Understanding how you will live in the building and who is living with you will need to be factored in for your designer to take the lead in advising you of the best system to suit your home.
Can you be involved during construction?
Whilst all of our drawings are created to the nearest millimetre and technical packages explain everything about how to build your project, we know that when it comes to construction, building is not an exact science. It is often likely that the end result will be constructed differently on site, with dimensions and some construction details being changed along the way. This might be down to a misinterpretation of drawings or other misunderstandings during construction. This may not have mattered so much 20 years ago, but it is particularly important now to check things during construction on-site. Once errors are built in, they can lead to potential problems further down the construction programme or, worse still, affect the performance of your building, permanently.
You should ideally try and have some form of involvement from your designer on site to help you and the builder address construction issues and explain why details matter. Things can quickly change where you or others don’t understand the impact of variations, which seem like a good idea at the time. Where your designer is available to check on the work being carried out, this could potentially save you disappointment and cost in the long run.
Many designers just supervise projects up to the planning application stage, but that only represents about 40% of what is going to be needed throughout the project. Having your designer on board for the next 60% of the project makes sense for your own peace of mind and will potentially save you and the builder from making expensive mistakes on-site.
Who will work on my project?
Building trust and confidence takes time, and this starts from the first meeting you have with your designer. So, you have been asking the right questions in selecting your designer and have answered them all well? You should now make sure that the person you have been speaking to will still be involved in the project. At ‘Ask the Expert’ sessions, we have spoken to self-builders who did their homework in selecting their designer, only to find that once the project started, that designer would no longer be involved in the project, and some more junior person was appointed. Make sure that key people stay involved throughout your project.
How am I protected?
As I mentioned at the outset, building your own home is one of your biggest investments. You may therefore want to have appropriate insurance cover should things go wrong. All Architects must carry professional indemnity insurance. This does offer you a degree of protection should something that they have detailed go wrong. In previous articles, we have discussed checking your designer’s credentials. We have lost count of the number of people I have met that have thought they had appointed an architect, only to find that they haven’t and therefore do not have any recourse to go back and get things corrected.
Using a designer who is a member of the RIBA or ARB is good, as these bodies can step in to help should you not be happy about the service you are being given. Always try and discuss any issues or problems with your designer first, and if they are credible, they will try their hardest to resolve the issue for you. The governing body is there to help; should your designer not be responsive to you.
In Summary
A good designer will listen to your needs and show you solutions that you may not have thought of, as well as consider what you already have in place. You are appointing a professional designer, so let them come up with designs to inspire and challenge you rather than just have them draw up what you suggest.
Coming up with a great design is challenging enough; however, you can see that you will need much more than this from your designer. A good designer will be thinking about all the complexities and costs you will encounter in making the design a reality, and take these into account during the design process
By running through the questions proposed here, I hope that you will find the journey with your designer to be a smooth and enjoyable experience as opposed to a continual battle which detracts from the main focus of realising your dream home.
Need some help with your self-build? At lapd Architects, we offer a free, no-obligation consultation. To book, contact us directly or use our online booking tool.
